In the beginning of January 2016, during the Presidential primary,
Trump’s Presidential campaign released their first T.V. ad in hopes of gaining supporters.
This commercial came amid a campaign that some would claim stunk of hate and Alt
Right rhetoric. In said ad you hear the narrator saying, “The politicians can
pretend it’s something else, but Donald Trump calls it radical Islamic
terrorism” as pictures of Hilary Clinton and President Obama strolled across
the screen. It then preaches of Trump’s proposal to “ban Muslims,” much as he
is saying now. It goes further to state that he is going to keep Muslims from
entering the U.S.A. until “we can figure out what’s going on.” The commercial
finishes up by telling the American people that Mr. Trump “will quickly cut the
head off of ISIS and take their oil” if elected President.
Fast forward to today, January 30, 2017- it appears President Trump is keeping at least part of that promise. He signed an executive order banning people from Iraq, Iran, Sudan, Somalia, Syria, Libya and Yemen from entering our country over the weekend in an effort to combat terrorism. There is also a lot of talk going on that there may be a "Muslim registry" implemented. That has not been officially confirmed as of now though. There's a lot of fear talking right now. We'll have to wait to see what actions Trump and his cabinet take in the next few months.
A few important facts about the newly issued orders from President Trump: around 0.01% of terrorist caught have actually came from those countries. The terrorist from 9/11 were 19 men, 15 of those men came from Saudi Arabia (which you will notice is missing from the ban list), 2 came from the United Arab Emirates (which is located in the middle of Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Oman on the Gulf Coast), and one came from Egypt.
Picture courtesy of Slate.com |
Now, what
you believe from there depends on which side of the political line you
straddle.
President Trump reports that this is NOT a Muslim ban. While
being interviewed this weekend about the detainments and deportations he said
this, “It’s not a Muslim ban, but we were totally prepared. You see it at the
airports, you see it all over. It’s working out very nicely, and we’re going to
have a very, very strict ban, and we’re going to have extreme vetting, which we
should have had in this country for many years.” Supporters are hailing this
move as necessary steps being taken by a “natural leader” who is a “work-a-holic”
and is “just getting started.” The White House seems to be happy with the ban
and the consequences of said ban on world travel and possibly even on world
terrorism. Trump's favorite lady, Kellyanne, even came out to Fox News in response to the ban telling Americans that, "This whole idea that they're being separated and ripped from their family... it's temporary." Families are also reporting that they were told the same thing by border agents. I guess that is supposed to make it better.
As with any political battle, his supporters and non-supporters alike have taken to social media to vent their feelings about the most recent actions of our Government. In response to Trump’s criticism a lot of his supporters are citing actions Barack Obama and Jimmy Carter took during their terms as President in regards to immigrant bans. They are using these examples as direct means to prove Liberals wrong. Why you ask? I seems this has become a Kindergarten shouting match between two sides of extremist that both should be listening to the people that are hanging out in the middle, worried and shaking their heads.
As with any political battle, his supporters and non-supporters alike have taken to social media to vent their feelings about the most recent actions of our Government. In response to Trump’s criticism a lot of his supporters are citing actions Barack Obama and Jimmy Carter took during their terms as President in regards to immigrant bans. They are using these examples as direct means to prove Liberals wrong. Why you ask? I seems this has become a Kindergarten shouting match between two sides of extremist that both should be listening to the people that are hanging out in the middle, worried and shaking their heads.
If you don’t know what they are talking about, here’s a quick
bit of information to catch you up.
According to Politifact.com in late 1979 an injustice was
committed against America. 60 of our American embassy personnel members in
Tehran were held captive. The culprits-Iranian militants. The hostage crisis
lasted for a reported 444 days. The actions that conservatives of today are
speaking of are the actions that President Carter took in response to that
situation. You see, in a bid to get the Iranians to end the hostage situation
Carter put forth a ban that kept Iranians from entering the United States
unless they opposed the Iranian Regime or had a medical emergency. As part of
this ban all Iranian students in America had to report to their local
immigration offices. This was done to determine if any had violated the terms
of their visa, if so they were deported. President Carter also halted the
issuing of new visas to Iranians. In 1980, the Times reported that almost 60,000
students had registered with immigration, less than 500 had been deported. By
the end, nearly 5,000 Iranians had left voluntarily, as a result of Carter’s
actions. Can’t see the difference in what Trump has done and what Carter did? Just
ask Kermit Roosevelt, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania. He is
quoted on Politifact.com as saying, “The difference [between Trump’s actions
and Carter’s actions] is that Iranians were citizens of, and owed allegiance
to, a country that was acting against the United States. The class of ‘all
Muslims’ has no similar connection to ISIS or terrorists. That makes the
analogy seriously flawed."
When it comes to the Conservative claims against President
Obama, they are referring to an executive order from 2011. In that 2011 order, The Daily Caller reports, Obama specifically called for a ban that covered
"anyone under a UN travel ban; anyone who violates any of 29 executive
orders regarding transactions with terrorists, those who undermine the
democratic process in specific countries, or transnational criminal
organizations." Again, this is different than banning a whole religion to
improve vetting processes. Obama’s executive order covered Iran, Syria, and
Crimea. Of the three, Iran and Syria are predominately Muslim countries. This
also making the circumstances different, his actions were NOT against a single
religion.
Now, back to the current situation at hand…
If you believe what the people are saying about the
aftermath of Trump’s ban, then you have a different viewpoint of what is going
on altogether. There are countless videos and reports coming from social media
and various outlets stating that in airports all over the United States
you see a very altered picture of reality then what President Trump is
depicting. Inside the airports were reported as being chaotic. Lawyers started
showing up Saturday night to help the refugees that were being refused entry. Some
of the people being detained were found to, reportedly, have Green Cards and
were still stopped. People from the 7 key Muslim countries were stopped, their
phone contacts and social media accounts reportedly searched, and them asked
how they felt about President Trump. Children and Grandparents detained. It
didn’t just happen in the U.S. either, airports all over the world are having
to turn away people flying to the U.S. that are from those countries. Many of
whom recently had visas approved and were headed here. They were already
vetted, yet they were detained, questioned, and refused entry.
When you turn your attention to what is going on outside airport
security then you get a real glimpse of what America is supposed to be about. You
see Americans standing up for what America is supposed to stand for. You see
humans out in masses, protesting what is being called the actions of a "want to
be dictator." You see airports full of men, women, and children holding signs
welcoming the refugees that are being detained inside, signs opposing Trump’s
ban. Over 5,000 showed up at JFK alone. The Taxi services to JFK Airport
protested as well, refusing to transport passengers as they arrived.
Protests at JFK Airport. Picture Courtesy of NyDailynews.com |
NY Taxi Workers Alliance's official statement about the ban |
Despite the Federal Judge’s ruling many reports are stating that border control officers are ignoring the court. They are sticking with what Homeland Security and President Trump ordered them to do. This includes, reportedly, coercing non-English speaking passengers into taking volunteer deportations and, in some cases, refusing civil rights lawyers access to immigrants being detained. The actions of the rogue Border Agents sent civil rights workers into overtime. In one case an Iranian Fulbright scholar was forced on to an AirUkraine flight at JFK-hours after agents had received the court order to stop. Reports are saying that in this instance that, “She was on the phone with us [her lawyers] and stood up [to exit] and asked to get off the flight; the crew just ignored her.” As a result of being ignored civil rights attorneys made frantic calls to higher-level officials-the plane was eventually turned around on the tarmac and the woman returned to detention, instead of being deported. Another media site reporting that a Mother refugee and her children were detained for over 20 hours without being offered food or water. Yet another story coming out reporting that a 5 year old boy was detained and kept from his mother, alone, for 5 hours.
Protests at Seatac Airport in Seatac, Washington. Picture Courtesy of q13fox.com |
Protesters in Boston. Picture Courtesy of chinanewsasia.com |
Want to read more from Brooke?
No comments:
Post a Comment